Archived information
Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please contact us to request a format other than those available.
Evaluation of Canada-Haiti Cooperation
2006-2013 - Synthesis Report
January 2015
Table of Contents
- List of Acronyms and Abbreviations
- Executive Summary
- 1.0 Introduction
- 2.0 Country Context and Information on the Cooperation Program
- 3.0 Key Findings
- 4.0 Development Results
- 5.0 Management Principles
- 5.1 Aid Coordination
- 5.2 Efficiency
- 5.3 Performance Management
- 6.0 Conclusions
- 7.0 Lessons
- 8.0 Recommendations
- Annex A: Summary of the Terms of Reference
- Annex B: Methodology
- Annex C: List of Projects Reviewed
- Annex D: List of Documents Reviewed
- Annex E: List of People Interviewed
- Annex F: Summary of Project Ratings by Programming Sector
- Annex G: Summary of Program and Project Ratings by CIDA Division
- Annex H: Summary of Ratings by Criterion and Sector
- Annex I: Humanitarian Assistance–Development Continuum
- Annex J: Follow-up Surveys of Fragile States – Haiti
- Annex K: Findings on Principles for Engagement in Fragile States
- Annex L: Guidelines for Classifying Findings in the Literature Review
- Annex M: Management Response
ANNEX F: Summary of Project Ratings by Programming Sector
For each sample project, the evaluation team conducted a literature review, interviews and field visits, including focus groups.
A rating was assigned to each indicator under each question per criterion, using guidelines established to classify findings from “highly unsatisfactory” to “highly satisfactory” (see Annex L). Each rating is shown in the tables below. Overall project ratings were obtained by calculating the average of all project indicator ratings.
Table 6: Health sector projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Fond santé et éducation II (volet santé) A032545001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Batilavi- Appui - quartiers défavorisés A032552001
Relevance: Not documented
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Highly unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfaisant
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: PARC –Renforcement des capacités gestion en santé A032604001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: PAPEV – vaccination A032606001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Highly unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Highly unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Unsatisfactory
Project Name: Projet d’Appui à la lutte contre les IST/VIH/SIDA en Haïti 2, A032673001 (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: PADESS-Développement du système santé A032705001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Amélioration - Santé de la reproduction - UNFPA A033878001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Reconstruction Hôpital des Gonaïves – UNOPS A034921002 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly satisfactory
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Integrated Community Health Care Project in Haiti Project - International Child Care S062053001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Operational Project Evaluation of Maternal Health Care Project - International Child Care S064143002 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: SCC /Providing Maternal and Child Health – Save the Children Canada S065296001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: SOGC / Secteur de la santé maternelle – S065319001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Table 7: Economic Growth and Food Security Sector Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Programme de développement local CECI/CRC Sogema Inc./ENAP/ SOCODEVI A031935001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Projet assistance technique Jacmel - Phase II A032087001 (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Not documented
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: ACOOPECH III Coop épargne et crédit A032462001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Route Les Cayes-Jérémie A033178001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly unsatisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Haiti Marketplace – Peace dividend Trust A034346001
Relevance: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Highly unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Unsatisfactory
Project Name: Relance de la production agricole – Oxfam Québec A034461001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Highly satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Pro Huerta – Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture A033962001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Système de financement et d'assurances(DID) A034860001 (V&E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Développement et Paix-Sécurité Alimentaire S065219001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Appui à la sécurité alimentaire Oxfam Québec S065314001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: L’intervention de Viva Rio dans La Zone De Bel Air» en Haïti A033886001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Rayjon: Integrated Rural Community Development” S064094001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Not documented
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Table 8: Education Sector Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Fond santé et éducation II (volet éducation) A032545001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Appui à l'école nouvelle Artibonite II (Fondation Paul Gérin-Lajoie) A021422001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Not documented
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: PEIA Éducation Intégrée en Artibonite A030547001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Crédit écolage (Desjardins) A033963001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Éducation pour tous A0342752 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Not documented
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Rentrée scolaire 08/09 A034551001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfaisant
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui aux cantines scolaires -WFP A035146001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Save the Children 2006-09 - 5 Years Program S062525PRG
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: CFPH CANADO (Formation Professionnelle) – Groupement Consortium international de développement en éducation S062897PRG
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Table 9: Governance Sector Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Joint Electoral Observation Mission to Haiti (2012) (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly unsatisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: FKF-Appui promotion du droit des femmes A020195001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Appui à la gouvernance locale dans le département du nord-est (AGLNE) A032551001 (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Highly unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly unsatisfactory
Coherence: Highly unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Unsatisfactory
Project Name: Appui aux média - Consortium Réseau Liberté et Alternatives A032554001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Programme d'appui au secteur de la justice - Agence Intergouvernementale de la Francophonie A032574001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui au cadre de coopération internationale - Embassy of Canada to Haïti A032640001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Projet d’appui au renforcement de la gestion publique (PARGEP) A033068001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui au Parlement haïtien - Parliamentary Centre A033069001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui aux droits des enfants et jeunes - Rights & Democracy A033870001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Highly satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Modernization of Haiti's Civil Registry A034034001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Projet de coopération municipale - Consortium FCM, UMQ et Ville de Montréal A035189001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Table 10: Rehabilitation and Reconstruction Sector Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Housing Action Project (Champ de Mars) - PNUD A035413001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Terre Sans Frontière - Reconstruction en éducation –Haïti S065291001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Désarmes Vocational Education and Economy S065297001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Annex G: Summary of Program and Project Ratings by CIDA Division
Table 11: Multilateral ProjectsFootnote 41
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: L’intervention de Viva Rio dans La Zone De Bel Air» en Haïti A033886001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Route Les Cayes-Jérémie A033178001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly unsatisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Éducation pour tous A0342752 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Not documented
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui aux cantines scolaires -WFP A035146001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Joint Electoral Observation Mission to Haiti (2012) (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly unsatisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui à la gouvernance locale dans le département du nord-est (AGLNE) A032551001 (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Highly unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly unsatisfactory
Coherence: Highly unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Unsatisfactory
Project Name: Modernization of Haiti's Civil Registry A034034001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Housing Action Project (Champ de Mars) - PNUD A035413001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: PAPEV – vaccination A032606001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Highly unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Highly unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Unsatisfactory
Project Name: Amélioration - Santé de la reproduction - UNFPA A033878001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Reconstruction Hôpital des Gonaïves – UNOPS A034921002 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly satisfactory
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Pro Huerta – Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture A033962001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Highly unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Table 12: Bilateral Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Programme de développement local CECI/CRC Sogema Inc./ENAP/ SOCODEVI A031935001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Projet assistance technique Jacmel - Phase II A032087001 (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Not documented
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: ACOOPECH III Coop épargne et crédit A032462001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Haiti Marketplace – Peace dividend Trust A034346001
Relevance: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Highly unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Unsatisfactory
Project Name: Relance de la production agricole – Oxfam Québec A034461001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Highly satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: CFPH CANADO (Formation Professionnelle) – Groupement Consortium international de développement en éducation S062897PRG
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Appui à l'école nouvelle Artibonite II (Fondation Paul Gérin-Lajoie) A021422001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Not documented
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: PEIA Éducation Intégrée en Artibonite A030547001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Crédit écolage (Desjardins) A033963001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Rentrée scolaire 08/09 A034551001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui aux média - Consortium Réseau Liberté et Alternatives A032554001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Programme d'appui au secteur de la justice - Agence Intergouvernementale de la Francophonie A032574001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Unsatisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui au cadre de coopération internationale - Embassy of Canada to Haïti A032640001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Projet d’appui au renforcement de la gestion publique (PARGEP) A033068001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui au Parlement haïtien - Parliamentary Centre A033069001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Appui aux droits des enfants et jeunes - Rights & Democracy A033870001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Highly satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Highly satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Projet de coopération municipale - Consortium FCM, UMQ et Ville de Montréal A035189001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Projet d’Appui à la lutte contre les IST/VIH/SIDA en Haïti 2, A032673001 (E)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: PADESS-Développement du système santé A032705001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Système de financement et d'assurances(DID) A034860001 (V&E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: PARC –Renforcement des capacités gestion en santé A032604001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Table 13: Partnerships Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Save the Children 2006-09 - 5 Years Program S062525PRG
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Terre Sans Frontière - Reconstruction en éducation –Haïti S065291001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Unsatisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Désarmes Vocational Education and Economy S065297001 (V)
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Highly satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Moderately satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Integrated Community Health Care Project in Haiti Project - International Child Care S062053001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Operational Project Evaluation of Maternal Health Care Project - International Child Care S064143002 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: SCC /Providing Maternal and Child Health – Save the Children Canada S065296001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Unsatisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: SOGC / Secteur de la santé maternelle – S065319001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Très insatisfaisant
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Unsatisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Très insatisfaisant
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: Développement et Paix-Sécurité Alimentaire S065219001 (V)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Highly satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Appui à la sécurité alimentaire Oxfam Québec S065314001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Rayjon: Integrated Rural Community Development” S064094001 (E)
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Satisfactory
Coherence: Unsatisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Not documented
Efficiency and Economy: Satisfactory
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Table 14: Local Funds Projects
V = Community Visit
E = Evaluated
Evaluation Criteria
Project Name: Fond santé et éducation II (volet santé) A032545001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Moderately satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Fond santé et éducation II (volet éducation) A032545001
Relevance: Satisfactory
Effectiveness: Satisfactory
Sustainability: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Highly satisfactory
Coherence: Satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
Project Name: Batilavi- Appui - quartiers défavorisés A032552001
Relevance: Not documented
Effectiveness: Moderately satisfactory
Sustainability: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Unsatisfactory
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Unsatisfactory
Coherence: Not documented
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Not documented
Performance Management: Highly unsatisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Moderately satisfactory
Project Name: FKF-Appui promotion du droit des femmes A020195001
Relevance: Highly satisfactory
Effectiveness: Highly satisfactory
Sustainability: Satisfactory
Effectiveness - Gender Theme: Not documented
Effectiveness - Environment Theme: Not documented
Coherence: Moderately satisfactory
Aid Effectiveness Principles: Moderately satisfactory
Performance Management: Moderately satisfactory
Principles for Engagement in Fragile States: Moderately satisfactory
Efficiency and Economy: Not documented
OVERALL: Satisfactory
